Black edition is my favourite butter so far! The smell is nice, manly but not overpowering. Does the beard wonders also. Got to thank Natalie too for the free face towel for my beard, she truely went above and beyond and I'm very greatful! Also the moustache comb is brilliant, buy it if you haven't already, its already trained in the direction i wanted it in without using wax or balm. Beard butter is the happy middle ground between oil and balm, zero residue